If God is all-powerful and all-good, why does He not eliminate evil? Freedom!

 


One of the most common objections to belief in God is the existence of evil. If God is all-powerful and all-good, why doesn't He simply eliminate evil? Why permit cruelty, betrayal, violence, and suffering?

Catholic theology offers several responses, but one of the most profound centers on a gift that most people cherish every day: freedom.

Freedom Is Not a Side Feature

Human freedom is not an accidental part of creation. It is central to what it means to be human.

We are not programmed machines carrying out pre-written instructions. We are capable of making choices, weighing alternatives, accepting responsibility, and shaping our own lives. We can choose honesty or deception, courage or cowardice, generosity or selfishness.

This freedom allows us to become moral beings rather than merely obedient creatures.

But freedom comes with an unavoidable consequence: the possibility of choosing wrongly.

Love Requires Freedom

Imagine a world in which every person was incapable of making a harmful choice.

No one could lie.

No one could steal.

No one could betray a friend.

No one could abuse power.

At first glance, such a world might sound ideal. But there is an important question to ask:

Could anyone genuinely love?

Love that is forced is not love. Love has value precisely because it is freely given. A spouse who remains faithful because there is literally no alternative is not choosing fidelity. A friend who helps because he is incapable of refusal is not exercising generosity.

The same freedom that allows us to reject goodness is the freedom that allows us to embrace it.

Without freedom, love would become impossible.

Eliminating Evil Means Eliminating Free Choice

People often imagine God removing evil while leaving everything else unchanged.

Catholic theology argues that things are not so simple.

To prevent every evil choice, God would have to intervene whenever a human being was about to make one.

The moment someone decided to lie, God would have to block the lie.

The moment someone decided to steal, God would have to stop the theft.

The moment someone decided to act selfishly, God would have to override that decision.

But where would such interventions end?

Human decisions are rarely simple. Nearly every action contains both good and bad possibilities. If God prevented every wrongful choice, He would eventually have to prevent every meaningful choice.

Freedom would become an illusion.

A World Without Evil Would Not Be a Human World

We often imagine a world without evil as being exactly like ours, except safer and happier.

Yet such a world might be fundamentally different.

There would be no moral agency because no one could make genuine moral decisions.

There would be no responsibility because choices would not truly belong to us.

There would be no courage because there would be no possibility of fear or failure.

There would be no forgiveness because there would be no wrongdoing.

There would be no sacrifice because there would be no cost.

Most strikingly, there would be no possibility of choosing love.

A world completely insulated from evil would also be a world stripped of the very qualities that make human beings human.

The Risk God Chose to Take

From a Catholic perspective, God judged that a world containing free persons capable of love was better than a world populated by creatures incapable of genuine choice.

That decision carried a cost.

Freedom opened the door not only to kindness, creativity, and heroism, but also to hatred, cruelty, and injustice.

The same freedom that allows a person to dedicate his life to serving others also allows another person to exploit, abuse, or harm.

Freedom is therefore both a magnificent gift and a tremendous responsibility.

God Does Not Abandon Humanity

The Christian answer is not that evil is good, or that suffering does not matter.

Rather, Christianity teaches that God permits freedom while continually working to bring good out of human failures and tragedies.

In Christian belief, God's response to evil is not detachment. It is involvement. The central claim of Christianity is that God entered human history, experienced suffering firsthand, and ultimately overcame evil not by abolishing freedom but by redeeming what freedom had damaged.

A Difficult but Meaningful Answer

This explanation does not remove every mystery surrounding evil and suffering. Some questions remain painful and difficult.

Yet it offers an important insight: eliminating evil is not as simple as flipping a cosmic switch.

To remove every possibility of evil would require removing every possibility of genuine freedom. And with freedom would disappear responsibility, virtue, growth, sacrifice, and love itself.

The existence of evil is not evidence that freedom has failed. It is evidence that freedom is real. And a world in which love can be freely chosen is also a world in which goodness must be freely chosen as well.

image and some content created by AI


Read more posts on Christianity: MSI Press Blog

Read more posts on spirituality: MSI Press Blog

Read more posts on theology: MSI Press Blog

Read more posts on good and evil: MSI Press Blog

post inspired by A Theology for the Rest of Us by Arthur Yavelberg

Book description

If God exists and is good, why is there evil? Avoiding such questions underlies the spiritual emptiness and anxiety in today's world. A Theology for the Rest of Us explores how to approach the divine through Eastern and Western religious traditions without dogma, challenging readers to "be you lamps unto yourselves."

In a time of internecine wars and all kinds of abuse of authority and trust, too many good, thoughtful people are "voting with their feet" and turning away from organized religion. Popular "spirituality"-a sort of mysticism-lite articulated in memes-is often unsatisfying as well.

A Theology for the Rest of Us is a straightforward approach to the fundamental questions of religion and philosophy:

- Does God exist?

- Is there free will?

- What is 'evil'?

This book draws on the traditions of the East as well as the West-Taoism, Buddhism and Hinduism in addition to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam-to see what can make sense in today's world. Whether exploring the implications of 17th century Enlightenment philosophers, quantum physics, or the insights of writers such as Dostoyevsky and Alan Watts, the reader is offered a rational, coherent approach that can provide understanding and a basis for hope in a world where the spirit has been all but decimated by doubt and worse.

Most important, the reader is encouraged to sift through these sources and choose what resonates and what does not. As the Buddha taught so many years ago, the Prime Directive is "Be ye lamps unto yourselves." A Theology for the Rest of Us makes teachings accessible to those who have already begun their spiritual journeys, validating their questions and showing that reasonable answers are available.


RECOMMENDED by the US Review of Books


A Theology for the Rest of Us has earned the following awards:

Best Indie Book Award
International Impact Book Award
Literary Titan Silver Aware
American BookFest Best Books Award finalist





Want to know more about Arthur and his book? Click HERE for more posts and HERE for the book trailer.






    CONTACT editor@msipress.com FOR A REVIEW COPY


    MSI Press, a veteran-owned publishing house based in California, United States
    best known for turning new writers into award-winning authors,
    has gained mass recognition for releasing highly acclaimed books of varying genres
    that are distributed internationally. Check us out on Wikitia.


    To purchase copies of any MSI Press book at 25% discount,

    use code FF25 at MSI Press webstore;

    for free shipping, use code ship4free.

    (Codes cannot be used together; they are meant to provide a choice of discount.)



    Want to read an MSI Press book and not have to pay for it?
    (1) Ask your local library to purchase and shelve it.
    (2) Ask us for a review copy; we love to have our books reviewed.


    VISIT OUR WEBSITE TO LEARN MORE ABOUT ALL OUR AUTHORS AND TITLES AND TO FOLLOW US ON OUR VARIOUS PLATFORMS.


    CONTACT INFO@MSIPRESS.COM TO SBUMIT A BOOK PROPOSAL/MAMUSCRIPT OR TO CONTACT ONE OF OUR AUTHORS.



    Sign up for the MSI Press LLC monthly newsletter: get inside information before others see it and access to additional book content: MSI Press 
    (recent releases, sales/discounts, awards, reviews, Amazon top 100 list, links to precerpts/excerpts, author advice, and more)

    Check out recent issues.


     

       

    MSI Press is ranked among the top publishers in California.
    Check out our rankings -- and more --
    HERE.

    Comments

    Popular posts from this blog

    Guest Post from Dr. Dennis Ortman: Words Matter

    In Memoriam: Carl Don Leaver

    Eternal Springs wins Literary Titan book award!