If We Are All Children of God, Why Do Religions Divide People into "Us" and "Them"?

 

Most religions teach some version of human unity.
Christians speak of all people as children of God.
Jews teach that all humanity shares a common origin.
Muslims believe that God created all people and calls them toward righteousness.
Many Eastern traditions emphasize compassion, interconnectedness, and respect for others.

If that is true, why do religious communities so often divide the world into "us" and "them"?

At first glance, this seems like a contradiction. But perhaps the answer lies not in theology alone, but in the nature of human communities. All groups create boundaries.
Families do.
Nations do.
Cultures do.
Sports teams do.
Religions do.

Without boundaries, a group ceases to be a group. To belong to a community means sharing something with other members of that community. It may be a language, a culture, a history, a set of beliefs, a common purpose, or a way of life.

Religious communities are no different. A church defines itself through certain beliefs. A synagogue defines itself through particular traditions. A mosque defines itself through shared faith and practice. These boundaries are not necessarily intended to exclude. They are often intended to preserve identity.

The problem begins when identity becomes superiority. There is a profound difference between saying:
"We believe this."
and saying:
"Only people like us matter."
The first statement creates a community. The second creates division. Unfortunately, human beings sometimes slide from one to the other. Part of the difficulty is psychological.

Religious convictions are often tied to our deepest values and most cherished beliefs. People may devote their entire lives to a faith tradition. They marry within it. Raise children within it. Build friendships within it. Find meaning within it. When something becomes central to identity, criticism can feel personal. Disagreement can feel threatening. Differences can become magnified. The result is that people sometimes begin viewing outsiders primarily through the lens of difference rather than shared humanity.

History provides many examples. Religions have inspired extraordinary acts of compassion, charity, education, healthcare, reconciliation, and service. The world's hospitals, schools, relief organizations, and humanitarian efforts bear abundant witness to that reality. At the same time, religious communities have sometimes participated in prejudice, exclusion, conflict, and even violence. The same commitment that motivates selfless service can, under certain circumstances, be transformed into tribalism.

The paradox is not unique to religion. It is a human problem. Religion simply provides another arena in which it appears. Perhaps the more interesting question is not why religions create an "us." Every community does that. The more interesting question is how religious traditions define the people outside that circle. Are outsiders enemies? Competitors? People to be feared? Or fellow human beings deserving dignity and respect? The answer often determines whether a religious community becomes a force for division or a force for unity.

Many of the great religious teachers seem to have wrestled with precisely this issue. Jesus repeatedly challenged his followers to love neighbors, strangers, and even enemies. Jewish teachings emphasize hospitality toward the stranger. The Qur'an speaks of humanity being created in diverse peoples and tribes so that they may know one another. Buddhist teachings encourage compassion that extends beyond one's immediate group.

Again and again, religious traditions appear to push believers beyond the natural tendency to limit concern to their own community. This may be one of the most difficult spiritual challenges human beings face. Creating an "us" comes naturally.
Expanding that "us" takes effort. Perhaps that is why mature religious faith is often characterized not by drawing sharper boundaries but by widening circles of concern. The goal is not to eliminate identity.
A Christian remains Christian.
A Jew remains Jewish.
A Muslim remains Muslim.
A Buddhist remains Buddhist.

The goal is something harder. The goal is to remain committed to one's own tradition while recognizing the humanity of those who stand outside it. In that sense, the question may not be whether religions divide people into "us" and "them." 

The deeper question is whether religion helps us remember that "they" are also part of God's creation. When religion succeeds at that task, "us" becomes larger than we imagined. And perhaps that is exactly what many religious traditions have been trying to teach all along.

image and some content from AI


post inspired by One Family Indivisible by Steven Greenebaum


Book Description:

Throughout history we have divided ourselves into groupings of "us" and "them". One Family: Indivisible engagingly invites the reader into the deeply spiritual and lifelong journey of the author to find a way to acknowledge our differences without dividing and subdividing ourselves into competing tribes. It is a journey of mountain tops and deep valleys, but it leads to the inclusivity and mutual respect possible with Interfaith. This is a book for seekers of all races, ethnicities, and spiritual paths who search for that elusive goal of a community of love and inclusion that also respects our diversity.



AWARDS
Eric Hoffer Award Category Finalist,
American Book Fest Best Books Award Finalist (religion)


Keywords: interfaith, spiritual journey, common humanity, religious diversity, unity in diversity, Jewish identity, interfaith minister, spiritual exploration, faith and belonging, inclusivity, religious harmony, finding common ground, embracing differences, beyond tribalism, coexistence, personal transformation, respect for all beliefs, universal spirituality, bridging faith traditions, compassion and connection




For more posts about Steven and this book, click HERE.

Read more interfaith posts: MSI Press Blog

Read posts about spiritual homelessness: MSI Press Blog

Read more posts about "us" vs "them": MSI Press Blog



Like this book? Check out Steven's acclaimed book on revelation for the 21st century, An Afternoon's Dictation. 

Book Description

    In 1999 Steven Greenebaum felt he'd hit the wall. Fifty years old, he could not make sense of his life or the world around him. For several months he angrily demanded answers from God, if God were there. One afternoon, an inner voice told him to get a pen and paper and write. Steven then took dictation - three pages, not of commandments but guidance for leading a meaningful life. 

    • An Afternoon's Dictation grapples with, organizes, and deeply explores the revelations Steven received and then studied for over ten years. His sharing is NOT offered as the only possible way to understand it the dictation. It is offered, rather, as a start. The book's sections include deep explorations into "The Call to Interfaith," "The Call to Love One Another," "The Call to Justice," and "The Call to Community." These explorations
      are rooted in a crucial part of the dictation that directs us to "Seek truth in the commonality of religions - which are but the languages of speaking to Me."
       
      Thus,
      An Afternoon's Dictation builds on what unites our diverse spiritual traditions, not what divides us. It shows us a path to respecting our differences while embracing unity of the great callings of our spiritual traditions. An Afternoon's Dictation provides caring guidance forward in these hugely challenging times - if we are open to it.

      Keywords:
      Interfaith, Spiritual Guidance, Divine Wisdom, Spiritual Journey, Religious Unity, Sacred Writing, Faith Exploration, Spiritual Awakening, Meaningful Life, Spiritual Unity, Divine Purpose, Spiritual Revelation, Faith and Purpose, Interfaith Harmony, Life Guidance, Sacred Wisdom, Spiritual Insight, Religious Commonality, Spiritual Seeker, Divine Message, Ecumenism

      Book Review: 5 stars from Literary Titan

      "An Afternoon's Dictation: Inclusive Revelation for the 21st Century offers a compelling and transformative narrative that propels us to interrogate our preconceptions about spirituality and espouse inclusivity as a route to mutual understanding. Greenebaum's passion for the subject matter radiates through each chapter, and his appeal for open-mindedness and discourse is both timely and pressing in our interconnected global ecosystem. A must-read, this book will undoubtedly appeal to those yearning to expand their spiritual landscape and nurture a more encompassing perspective on life. ... This thoughtfully constructed work masterfully intertwines the author's personal encounters, philosophical observations, and historical allusions to offer an innovative approach to spirituality that is exceedingly pertinent to the contemporary global scenario."

      Awards this book has earned
      Winner. London Book Festival
      Literary Titan gold award
      Indies Today runner-up
      Firebird Book Awards honorable mention
      Pacific Book Award finalist (runner-up)
      The BookFest honorable mention
      Chanticleer International Book Awards finalist
      American Legacy Book Awards finalist
      Pinnacle Book Achievement Award


CONTACT editor@msipress.com FOR A REVIEW COPY


MSI Press, a veteran-owned publishing house based in California, United States
best known for turning new writers into award-winning authors,
has gained mass recognition for releasing highly acclaimed books of varying genres
that are distributed internationally. Check us out on Wikitia.


To purchase copies of any MSI Press book at 25% discount,

use code FF25 at MSI Press webstore;

for free shipping, use code ship4free.

(Codes cannot be used together; they are meant to provide a choice of discount.)



Want to read an MSI Press book and not have to pay for it?
(1) Ask your local library to purchase and shelve it.
(2) Ask us for a review copy; we love to have our books reviewed.


VISIT OUR WEBSITE TO LEARN MORE ABOUT ALL OUR AUTHORS AND TITLES AND TO FOLLOW US ON OUR VARIOUS PLATFORMS.


CONTACT INFO@MSIPRESS.COM TO SBUMIT A BOOK PROPOSAL/MAMUSCRIPT OR TO CONTACT ONE OF OUR AUTHORS.



Sign up for the MSI Press LLC monthly newsletter: get inside information before others see it and access to additional book content
(recent releases, sales/discounts, awards, reviews, Amazon top 100 list, links to precerpts/excerpts, author advice, and more)

Check out recent issues.


 

   

MSI Press is ranked among the top publishers in California.
Check out our rankings -- and more --
HERE.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Guest Post from Dr. Dennis Ortman: Words Matter

In Memoriam: Carl Don Leaver

Eternal Springs wins Literary Titan book award!